Amanda SeyfriedAnn Lee
Lewis PullmanWilliam Lee
Thomasin McKenzieMary Partington / Narrator
Matthew BeardJames Whittaker
Christopher AbbottAbraham Standerin
Viola PrettejohnNancy Lee
David CaleJohn Hocknell
Stacy MartinJane Wardly
Scott HandyJames Wardley
Jeremy WheelerJohn Townley
Tim Blake NelsonPastor Reuben Wight
Daniel BlumbergDeacon Talmadge Bishop
Willem van der VegtAnn's Father
Maria SandAnn's Mother
Millie-Rose CrossleyAnn Lee (12 Yrs)
Esmee HewettAnn Lee (6 Yrs)
Harry ConwayWilliam Lee (10 Yrs)
Benjamin BagotaWilliam Lee (4 Yrs)
Scott Alexander YoungChief Magistrate Tideswell
George TaylorGeorge Whitefield
Jamie BogyoRichard Hocknell
Matti BoustedtCaptain Smith
Alexis LathamMr. Cunningham
Shannon WoodwardMrs. Cunningham
Lark WhitePatsy
Roy McCrereyMr. Shattuck
Viktória DányiMrs. Shattuck
Natalie ShinnickElizabeth Hale
Maddie BrowningYoung Mother
Martin O'ReganDutchman
Francis McBurneyInfirmary Guard
Alex GregorConstable #1
Chris JacksonConstable #2
Lukas JohneJailer
Áron HavasiJailer #2
Freya EdmondesInmate
Owen GoodClergyman
James HoggOlder Deckhand
David FjällbrantYoung Deckhand #1
Melker AppelYoung Deckhand #2
Laurent WinklerBuilder
Zachary ZamskyRuffian #1
Jack LeGoffRuffian #2
Maggie NicolsTownley Woman
Christina LeonardiYoung Shaker Woman
Joseph FosterShaker Singer
Sasha BatesAdam
Mattie VoglerEve
Emily Leona RoseAngel
Vivien PitiLewd Woman
Gergely CserhatiJacob
