Alexander MolonyPeter Pan
Ever AndersonWendy Darling
Jude LawCaptain Hook
Alyssa WapanatâhkTiger Lily
Jim GaffiganSmee
Joshua Blue PickeringJohn Darling
Jacobi JupeMichael Darling
Molly ParkerMrs. Darling
Alan TudykMr. Darling
Yara ShahidiTinker Bell
Florence BensbergCurly
Sebastian Billingsley-RodriguezNibs
Noah Matthews MatofskySlightly
Caelan EdieTootles
Kelsey YatesTwin 1
Skyler YatesTwin 2
Diana TsoyBirdie
Felix de SousaBellweather
John DeSantisBill Jukes
Garfield WilsonGurley
Ian TraceySallyport
Mark AchesonOld Clemson
Jesse James PierceSkylight
Gemita SamarraMermaid
Cassie Van WoldeAdult Wendy
Deborah RamsayOlder Wendy
Paloma NuñezMrs. Starkey
Paul Chih-Ping ChengScrimshaw Sam
Mike ChingDirtbag Benny
Nora McadamTiger Lily's Grandmother
Steve HuntPirate Chorus Member
Roy DilbertPirate Chorus Member
Nick PrestonPirate Chorus Member
Arthur Lee RosePirate Chorus Member
Jason DemidoffPirate Chorus Member
Tony Chris KazoleasPirate Chorus Member
Boyd FergusonGundeck Pirate
Atlin MitchellJolly Roger Pirate
Chad BellamyJolly Roger Pirate
Danny HospesJolly Roger Pirate / Gangly Pirate
Darryl QuonJolly Roger Pirate
Fraser AitchesonJolly Roger Pirate
Jason DayJolly Roger Pirate
Joshua MazerolleJolly Roger Pirate
Nathaniel ShukerJolly Roger Pirate
Ryan HandleyJolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate
Jack KingsleyJolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate
Lars GrantJolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate
Mark KryskoJolly Roger Pirate / Skull Rock Pirate
Curtis BraconnierSkull Rock Pirate
Trevor AddieSkull Rock Pirate
Will ErichsonSkull Rock Pirate
Brad KellySkull Rock Pirate
Marshall BinghamSkull Rock Pirate
Angela UyedaSkull Rock Pirate
Eclilson de JesusSkull Rock Pirate
Chanelle HunterPeter's Shadow
Matt ReimerHook's Shadow