Carey MulliganFelicia Montealegre
Bradley CooperLeonard Bernstein
Matt BomerDavid Oppenheim
Vincenzo AmatoBruno Zirato
Greg HildrethIsaac
Michael UrieJerry Robbins
Brian KlugmanAaron Copeland
Nick BlaemireAdolph Green
Mallory PortnoyBetty Comden
Alexandra SantiniClaudio's Guest #1
Jarrod LaBineClaudio's Guest #2
Sarah SilvermanShirley Bernstein
Kate EastmanEllen Adler
William HillJoseph the Janitor
Valéry LessardYounger Actress
Renée StorkOlder Actress
Tim RoganRichard Hart
Sara SandersonLil Hart
Yasen PeyankovSerge Koussevitzky
Julia AkuOlga
Benjamin FreemantleSailor
Harrison CollSailor
Sebastian Villarini-VelezSailor
Dario NatarelliSailor
Ryan SteeleSailor
Ricky UbedaSailor
Carlos Sánchez FalúBartender
Jeanette DelgadoFancy Free Woman
Sara EstyFancy Free Woman
Ahmad SimmonsNYC Pedestrian Man Dancer
Kyle CoffmanNYC Pedestrian Man Dancer
Byron TittleNYC Pedestrian Man Dancer
Yesenia AyalaNYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer
Skye MattoxNYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer
Halli TolandNYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer
Leigh-Ann EstyNYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer
Gaby DiazNYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer
Tanairi Sade VazquezNYC Pedestrian Woman Dancer
Lea CooperLittle Jamie
Soledad CamposJulia Vega
Zachary BoothMendy Wager
Miriam ShorCynthia O'Neal
Maya HawkeJamie Bernstein
Scott EllisHarry Kraut
James Cusati-MoyerGeorgie
John KroftYoung Man
Scott DrummondScott
Gideon GlickTommy Cothran
Josh HamiltonJohn Gruen
June GableOld Lady
Sam NivolaAlexander Bernstein
Alexa SwintonNina Bernstein
Mike MitarotondoBellhop
Colin AndersonStage Manager
Kevin ThompsonDirector
Rosa FeolaEly Soloist #1
Isabel LeonardEly Soloist #2
Miller BugliariMiller
Atika GreeneNurse
Bernard KrugerDr. Kruger
Gabe FazioWillard the Assistant
Jordan DobsonWilliam
Oscar PavloClaudio Arrau (uncredited)
Eric Patrick CameronAudience Member (uncredited)